
James Howells' Lost Bitcoin: Court Ends Bid to Search Landfill for 8,000 BTC
Welsh IT worker James Howells says he mined 8,000 bitcoin in 2009, when they were practically worthless. In 2013, the hard drive containing the keys ended up in the rubbish by mistake during a clear-out – and then in a landfill site in Newport, Wales. For more than ten years, he has been trying to get it back.
The legal battle
Howells repeatedly asked Newport City Council for permission to search the site. He offered to give part of the proceeds to the community. The council refused, citing environmental risks and its licence for the landfill. Howells eventually took the council to court and claimed damages.
Court rulings in 2025
On 9 January 2025, the High Court dismissed the case: the claim had no realistic prospect of success, and too much time had passed. On 13 March 2025, the Court of Appeal refused permission to appeal. Howells announced that he would take the case to the European Court of Human Rights.
What the coins are worth
At prices in spring 2025, the 8,000 BTC would be worth more than 600 million pounds. Even if the hard drive were found, it is unclear whether the data would still be readable after so many years in the landfill.
The lesson
Bitcoin is only as safe as your backup. A recovery phrase written down on paper or metal and kept in a safe place would have made the hard drive irrelevant – the coins could have been restored at any time.









